aDepartment of Pharmaceutics and Industrial Pharmacy, Faculty of Pharmacy, Al-Azhar University, Egypt, bDepartment of Pharmaceutics, Faculty of Pharmacy, October University for Modern Science and Arts (MSA) University, Egypt
Email: gyassin@msa.eun.eg
Received: 13 Mar 2016 Revised and Accepted: 17 May 2016
ABSTRACT
Objective: The objective of the present work was to develop and optimize fast dissolving orodispersible films containing metoclopramide hydrochloride using 32 multifactorial designs.
Methods: The films were prepared by solvent casting method using hydroxypropyl methyl cellulose E5 (HPMC E5) and sodium starch glycolate (SSG) as two independent variables in three levels in concentration 2.5, 3, 3.5% w/wand 1, 1.5, and 2 % respectively. The percent of in vitro drug release (Y1) and the disintegration time (Y2) were chosen and studied as dependent responses. The prepared films were also evaluated for their weight uniformity, thickness, surface pH, drug content, in vitro disintegration time, in vitro drug release, film stability and mechanical properties as folding endurance.
Results: All the films were transparent. The films weight (mg) was ranging from 63±0.78 to 86±0.82 while the film thickness (mm) and the folding endurance range from 0.22±0.53, 50±0.58 to 0.32±0.35 and 90±0.84 respectively. The drug content (mg %) was studied, and it ranges from 98.24±1.08 to 99.07±1.02. It was found that the relative standard deviation (% RSD) met the criteria of USP specification for drug content (>6%). In vitro disintegration time was tested; all films satisfied the requirement of disintegration time for fast dissolving dosage form ( > 1 min), it ranged from 2.24±1.75 to 3.18±1.87 sec. The stability studies revealed no significant differences before and after storage for the all formulations.
Conclusion: An optimized metoclopramide HCl film was achieved that could be a benefit to a patient suffering from emesis, in which hydroxypropyl methylcellulose (E5) was used as a film forming polymer in its high level (3.5%) in addition to sodium starch glycolate in its high level (2%).
Keywords: Fast dissolving orodispersible films, Optimization, Metoclopramide HCL, 32multifactorial designs
© 2016 The Authors. Published by Innovare Academic Sciences Pvt Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/)
INTRODUCTION
A fast dissolving oral film (FDF) has been successfully used to deliver medicines to patients having difficulty in swallowing, those with oral pain due to mucositis or after oral surgery, or those with nausea. Several film preparations have been developed for analgesics such as ketrolac [1] or fentanyl [2, 3], the antiemetic agent prochlorperazine [4] and Ca2+channel antagonist verapamil [5].
Fast-dissolving oral delivery systems are solid dosage forms, which disintegrate or dissolve within 1 min when placed in the mouth without drinking or chewing [6].
The first developed fast-dissolving dosage form consisted in tablet form, and the rapid disintegrating properties were obtained through a special process or formulation modifications [7]. More recently, fast-dissolving films are gaining interest as an alternative to fast-dissolving tablets to eliminate definitely patients’ fear of choking and overcome patent impediments. Fast-dissolving films are generally constituted of plasticized hydrocolloids or blends made of them that can be laminated by solvent casting or hot-melt extrusion [8].
Common problems are caused by foaming during the film formation due to the heating of the material or solvent evaporation, the flaking during the slitting and the cracking in the cutting phase. Furthermore, the films should be stable to moisture over time. Finally, to facilitate the handling they have to be flexible and exhibit a suitable tensile stress and do not stick to the packaging materials and fingers.
Metoclopramide was chosen as a model drug, the drug selection based on a high frequency of prescribing, an appropriate indication and the age for this new dosage form.
Metoclopramide hydrochloride is a white crystalline, odorless substance, and its freely soluble in water. It is used as an anti-emetic in the treatment of some forms of nausea and vomiting associated with cancer therapy, pregnancy, migraine, etc., and to increase gastrointestinal motility [9]. However the oral bioavailability of metoclopramide HCl is highly variable showing values between 32 and 98 % due to expensive pre-systemic metabolism [10, 11]. This work aims to formulate, design and optimize fast dissolving orodispersible films of metoclopramide HCL at various concentration of film-forming polymer (HPMC E5) and super-disintegrant (sodium starch glycolate) by using32 multi-factorial design and to evaluate their influence on the percent of in vitro drug release and the disintegration time.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Materials
Metoclopramide Hydrochloride, hydroxypropyl methylcellulose (HPMC), and sodium starch glycolate (SSG) were obtained as gift sample by Sedico for Pharmaceuticals (6 of October, Giza, Egypt). Other chemicals were purchased from ADWEC, Egypt and they were of analytical grade.
Preliminary trials
Selection of polymer
Different grades of HPMC (k4m and E5) were tried for the preparation of fast dissolving orodispersible films (FDF). HPMC k4m did not show a good result, the film was not easily peelable, sticky in nature and did not give good films.
HPMC E5 was selected for the formulation of films as it forms good easily peelable and non-sticky films.
Preparation of the films
The fast dissolving films were prepared by a solvent casting method. The required percentage of polymer solution (HPMC E5) (2.5, 3, and 3.5% w/w) was prepared by dispersing the polymer powder in distilled water with continuous stirring at 70 °C. After continuous stirring the solution was left undisturbed for five to eight hours to remove all the air bubbles. Accurately weighed quantity of drug, plasticizer and all other excipients was separately dissolved in distilled water in another beaker. After complete hydration of the polymer with water, drug-plasticizer and all other excipient solutions were added and mixed thoroughly, and the volume was made up 30 milliliters with distilled water. The polymeric solutions were then poured on the mold, allowed to dry at 45 °C. The resultant films were cut into the dimension of 2x2 cm2 in size in which 10 mg of metoclopramide hydrochloride was included [5, 12]. The prepared films are packed immediately after the reparation in individual airtight aluminum seal packs and stored at 25 °C until use.
Experimental design and statistical analysis
A 32-factor, 3-level factorial design was used to explore response surfaces and constructing second-order polynomial models with statgraphic plus software (Version 4.1). The 3-level factorial design was specifically selected since it requires fewer runs than other experimental designs. The nonlinear computer, generated quadratic model is given as (equation 1): Y=β0+β1 X1+β2 X2+β12 X1X2+β11 X12+β22 X22
Where Y is the predicted response (dependent variable); β0 is the model constant (arithmetic mean response); X1and X2 are the independent variables and represent the average result of changing one factor at a time from its low value to the higher one; The terms X1X2 represent the changes of response when the two factors are simultaneously changed; The terms X1X1 and X2X2 are used to indicate non linearity; β1 and β2 are the linear coefficients; β12 are the cross-product coefficient; and β11, and β22 are the quadratic coefficients. 3-level design, where selected each variable is tested at a low (-1), medium (0) and high (+1) level. The percent of in vitro drug release (Y1) and the disintegration time (Y2) were chosen and studied as dependent responses. Nine Metoclopramide hydrochloride FDF formulations were prepared according to 32full factorial designs to optimize the formulation factors and evaluate the main effects. The independent variables were the polymer % (HPMC E5) (X1) and superdisintegrant % (SSG) (X2). Three levels of HPMC E5 % were used 2.5, 3 and 3.5%, denoted the value-1, 0 and 1in the above design respectively.
Three levels of SSG concentration were chosen to be 1 %, 1.5 % and 2 % denoted-1, 0 and 1 respectively are represented in table 1. The nine experimental trials and the respective observed responses are given in table 2.
Table 1: Independent variables and the selected levels for metoclopramide oro-dispersible film formulations
Factor |
Low(-1) |
Medium (0) |
High(1) |
X1 (HPMC E5 % w/w) X2 (SSG % w/w) |
2.5 1 |
3 1.5 |
3.5 2 |
Table 2: Variables and observed response in 32 factorial design of metoclopramide orodispersible film formulations
Formulation |
Independent variables |
Dependent variables |
|||||
Predicted values |
observed values |
||||||
X1 |
X2 |
Y1 |
Y2 |
Y1 |
Y2 |
||
F1 |
-1 |
0 |
93.57±2.12 |
3.00±1.30 |
94.16 |
2.76 |
|
F2 |
1 |
-1 |
94.62±3.74 |
2.57±2.20 |
94.28 |
2.89 |
|
F3 |
0 |
1 |
92.76±1.72 |
3.10±3.05 |
92.50 |
3.01 |
|
F4 |
1 |
-1 |
90.32±2.05 |
2.24±1.75 |
90.04 |
2.14 |
|
F5 |
0 |
1 |
93.213.21 |
2.45±0.98 |
92.89 |
2.40 |
|
F6 |
-1 |
0 |
90.75±1.75 |
2.50±0.53 |
94.28 |
2.37 |
|
F7 |
1 |
-1 |
93.21±3.08 |
3.00±1.75 |
92.05 |
3.06 |
|
F8 |
0 |
1 |
95.32±0.52 |
3.18±1.87 |
96.80 |
2.90 |
|
F9 |
1 |
-1 |
100.00±0.56 |
2.52±2.00 |
98.82 |
2.73 |
X1= % w/w of polymer (hydroxpropylmethyl cellulose-HPMC E5), X2=% w/w of superdisintegrant (sodium starch glycolate-SSG), Y1= % of in vitro drug release, Y2= disintegration time (sec)
Table 3: Composition and codes of metoclopramide orodispersible film formulations
Components |
Formula code |
||||||||
F1 |
F2 |
F3 |
F4 |
F5 |
F6 |
F7 |
F8 |
F9 |
|
Metoclopramide (g) HPMC E5*(g) SSG*(g) Glycerol (ml) Citric acid (g) Mannitol (g) Aspartame (g) Purified water(ml) to |
0.65 2.5 1 2 0.2 0.04 0.04 100 |
0.65 3 1 2 0.2 0.04 0.04 100 |
0.65 3.5 1 2 0.2 0.04 0.04 100 |
0.65 2.5 1.5 2 0.2 0.04 0.04 100 |
0.65 3 1.5 2 0.2 0.04 0.04 100 |
0.65 3.5 1.5 2 0.2 0.04 0.04 100 |
0.65 2.5 2 2 0.2 0.04 0.04 100 |
0.65 3 2 2 0.2 0.04 0.04 100 |
0.65 3.5 2 2 0.2 0.04 0.04 100 |
*HPMC E5: Hydroxypropyl methylcellulose E5, * SSG: Sodium starch glycolate
Physical appearance of the film
Appearances of the films such as transparent or opaque were evaluated by visual observation [8, 13].
Weight uniformity of the film
The weight of film strip (2x2 cm) of metoclopramide hydrochloride was determined by an analytical balance (Shimazdu, Japan) [8]. Experiments were carried out in triplicates.
Thickness of the film
Film thickness was measured by means of a micrometer (precision± 0.0001 mm Mitutoyo Corporation, Japan). The thickness of each film was measured at three different positions of the film and the average thickness was calculated [5]. Experiments were carried out in triplicates.
Folding endurance study
It was measured manually for the prepared fast dissolving film (2 Χ 2 cm). A strip was repeatedly folded at the same place till it broke. The number of times the film could be folded at the same place without breaking gave the value of folding endurance. This test was performed on three films of each formulation [14].
Surface pH
The surface pH of fast dissolving strip was determined in order to investigate the possibility of any side effects in vivo. As an acidic or alkaline pH may cause irritation to the oral mucosa, it was determined to keep the surface pH as close to neutral as possible. A combined pH electrode was used for this purpose. Oral strip was slightly wet with the help of water. The pH was measured by bringing the electrode in contact with the surface of the oral film (Orion Research, Inc., USA). This study was performed on three films of each formulation [15].
Drug content determination
The content uniformity of each oral film was tested for metoclopramide HCl using UV spectroscopy at 273 nm. One fast-dissolving film of 2 cm x 2 cm was selected and dissolved in 100 ml of phosphate buffer pH 6.8 then the concentration of the drug was determined from a previously constructed standard calibration curve. According to the USP standards, the contents of preparations should lay between the limits 98 to 101%. The results were expressed as mean of three determinations of each formulation [16].
In vitro disintegration studies
Disintegration time gives an indication about the disintegration characteristics and dissolution characteristics of the film. The film as per the dimensions (2 x 2 cm) required for dose delivery was placed on a stainless steel wire mesh placed in a petri dish containing 10 ml phosphate buffer pH 6.8 at 37 °C. Time required for the film to break was noted as in vitro disintegration time. This test was performed on three films of each formulation [17, 18].
In vitro drug release
The in vitro dissolution test of metoclopramide HCl films was performed three times using (900 ml; phosphate buffer pH 6.8 with USP paddle dissolution apparatus II (Hanson SR8-plus 80, USA) at 50 rpm and 37±0.5 °C temperature. The drug release was analyzed spectrophotometrically at λ max 273 nm using ultraviolet (UV) spectrophotometer by using a previously prepared calibration. One film was placed into each vessel and test sample (5 ml) was withdrawn at particular time interval (10, 20, 30, 40, 60 and 90 Seconds) and replaced with fresh dissolution media maintained at 37±0.5 °C. In order to prevent the film strips from floating, each strip was fixed to a glass slab and placed at the bottom of the dissolution vessel before starting the dissolution test [19].
Accelerated stability studies
The prepared films were packed and subjected to stability studies at 40 °C/75 % relative humidity (RH) for a period of 3 mo. Samples were withdrawn at time intervals of 15 d and evaluated for physical parameters, pH, drug content, and drug release [20].
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Characterization of fast dissolving films
Metoclopramide orodispersible films prepared were transparent, colorless, thin and with no spots on the film surface. The prepared film was evaluated for the following parameters: Physical Appearance of the film, weight uniformity of the film, the thickness of the film, folding endurance study, surface pH, drug content determination and in vitro disintegration studies as shown below in table 4.
All the films were transparent. The films weight (mg) was ranging from 63± 0.78 to 86± 0.82 while the film thickness (mm) and the folding endurance range from 0.22±0.53, 50±0.58 to 0.32±0.35 and 90±0.84 respectively. The drug content (mg %) was studied and it range from 98.24± 1.08 to 99.07±1.02. It was found that the relative standard deviation (% RSD) met the criteria of USP specification for drug content (>6%) [21].
In vitro disintegration time was tested; all films satisfied the requirement of disintegration time for fast dissolving dosage form ( > 1 min), it ranged from 2.24±1.75-3.18±1.87 sec.
Table 4: Physical appearance, weight uniformity, thickness, folding endurance, pH, and drug content and in vitro disintegration of metoclopramide films
Formulations |
Physical appearance |
Weight uniformitya |
Thickness (mm)a |
Folding endurancea |
pHa |
Drug content (mg %)a |
In vitro disintegration (sec)a |
F1 |
Transparent |
66.00±0.23 |
0.24±0.5 |
50±0.58 |
6.80±0.2 |
98.81±1.17 |
3.00±1.30 |
F2 |
Transparent |
76.00±0.56 |
0.23±0.14 |
58±0.47 |
6.90±2.4 |
98.24±1.08 |
2.57±2.20 |
F3 |
Transparent |
63.00±0.78 |
0.31±0.81 |
60±0.59 |
7.05±1.4 |
99.05±1.51 |
3.10±3.05 |
F4 |
Transparent |
76.00±1.25 |
0.32±0.35 |
60±1.44 |
7.08±0.8 |
99.47±0.68 |
2.24±1.75 |
F5 |
Transparent |
63.00±3.01 |
0.28±0.42 |
64±1.12 |
6.94±1.7 |
98.84±0.73 |
2.45±0.98 |
F6 |
Transparent |
76.00±2.73 |
0.24±0.14 |
67±0.64 |
6.85±1.1 |
98.39±0.71 |
2.50±0.53 |
F7 |
Transparent |
70.00±2.10 |
0.22±0.53 |
80±1.04 |
6.91±1.0 |
98.47±1.31 |
3.00±1.75 |
F8 |
Transparent |
86.00±0.82 |
0.30±0.81 |
82±1.01 |
6.87±0.8 |
98.64±1.24 |
3.18±1.87 |
F9 |
Transparent |
75.00±0.75 |
0.27±0.24 |
90±0.84 |
7.08±0.5 |
99.07±1.02 |
2.52±2.00 |
amean±SD, n=3.
In vitro drug release
The in vitro drug release of different films was investigated and the results are represented in fig. 1. The release of metoclopramide from its film can be ranked in the following descending order: F9>F4>F8>F2>F5=F7>F1>F3>F6 where the amount of drug release after 30 min was found to be 100%, 97.3%, 95.32%, 94.62 %, 93.21%, 93.57%, 92.76% and 90.75%, respectively.
Formulations F9 was observed to have the highest release, this was due to the presence of the highest concentration of water soluble hydrophilic polymers (HPMC E5 3.5%) which dissolves rapidly and introduce porosity. The void volume is thus expected to be occupied by the external solvent which diffuses into the film and thereby accelerate dissolution. Also the presence of SSG (2%) which act as super disintegrant increase the rate of film disintegration. The results of metoclopramide films are in agreement with Raju et al., [22], who showed that the presence of highest concentration of water soluble hydrophilic polymers (HPMC E5) increases the release from the prepared films. Also the increase in the amount of hydrophilic carrier leads to the increase in the wettability and dispersibility of the drug from the film resulting in the dissolution of the film. [23] This result is matched with that observed in the enhancement of dissolution of fenofibrate. [24]
Optimization of formulation using 32 multifactorial designs
Nine metoclopramide hydrochloride FDF formulations were prepared according to 32full factorial designs to optimize the formulation factors and evaluate the main effects. The independent variables were the polymer percent (HPMC E5) (X1) and super disintegrant percent (SSG) (X2). Three levels of HPMC E5 percent were used 2.5, 3 and 3.5%, denoted the value-1, 0 and 1in the above design respectively.
Fig. 1: In vitro drug release of fast dissolving orodispersible films (F1-F9)
Three–dimensional (3D) plots and standard pareto chart for the percent of in vitro drug release (Y1) and the disintegration time (Y2) were chosen and studied as dependent responses and were drawn using stat graphics plus design software (version 4.1) is shown in fig. 2-3 respectively.
Contour plots were prepared for all the three responses Y1, Y2 andY3 are shown in fig 8-10 c. These plots are used to study the interaction effects i.e. the effects of two factors at one time. The observed and the predicted values were shown in table 2 while the R-squared values were represented in table 5.
The response Y1 which is the percent of in vitro drug release is represented by the following polynomial equation (equation 2):
Y1 =113.29+13.49 X1-62.11 X2-3.79 X12+7.6X1X2+13.94 X22
Where, Y1 is the percent of in vitro drug release, X1 is the polymer percent, and X2 is the superdisintegrant percent. The polynomial equation was generated by multiple linear regressions. The percent of in vitro drug releasevalues are dependent on the selected independent variables. The fitted equation relates the response (the percent of in vitro drug release) to the transformed factor as shown by equation 2. The results of regression analysis revealed that on increasing the value of X1, the percent of in vitro drug release increases and this is observed by the positive sign coefficient of β1 (the linear coefficient). While the percent of in vitro drug release was noticed to be decreased as the values of X2 increase, this was noticed by the negative sign of β2 (the linear coefficient).
The response Y2 which is the disintegration timeis represented by the following polynomial equation (equation 3):
Y2 =248.46+59.4 X1-254.8 X2-1.6 X12–34.8X1X2+119.6 X22
The fitted equation relates the response (the disintegration time) to the transformed factor as shown by equation 2. The results of regression analysis revealed that on increasing the value of X1, the disintegration time increases and this is observed by the positive sign coefficient β1 (the linear coefficient). While the disintegration time was noticed to be decreased as the values of X2 increase, this was noticed by the negative sign of β1 (the linear coefficient).
Regression analysis of the data was carried out in statistical analysis system (SAS) by a special cubic model. From ANOVA study on the data of the percent of in vitro drug release (Y1) and the disintegration time (Y2) is shown in table 5, the standard error was below 5%, indicating that the observed responses were very close to predicted values. The Durbin-Watson (DW) statistic tests the residual to determine if there is any significant correlation between data, since the DW value is greater than 1.4, there is probably not any serious autocorrelation in the residuals.
The promising formulation was selected on the basis of the accepted criteria of percent of in vitro drug release (Y1) anddisintegration time (Y2). From the obtained results, hydroxypropyl methyl cellulose (E5) as a film forming polymer was used inits high level (3.5%) in addition to sodium starch glycolate in its high level (2%). These criteria were found in formulation F9 as the observed values were very close to the predicted ones as shown in table 6.
(a)
(b)
(c)
Fig. 2: (2. a) Response surface plot, (2. b) Standard pareto chart and, (2. c) contour plot showing the effect of X1 and X2 on the drug release after 30 min. (Y1)
(a)
(b)
(c)
Fig. 3: (3. a) Response surface plot, fig. (3. b) standard pareto chart and fig. (3. c) contour plot showing the effect of X1 and X2 on disintegration time (Y2)
Table 5: Summary of results of regression analysis for responses Y1 (percent of in vitro drug release) and Y2 (disintegration time)
Response |
R2 |
Adjusted R2 |
Standard error |
Mean absolute error |
Durbin-Watson statistic |
In vitro drug release |
88.137 |
68.366 |
1.598 |
0.780 |
2.040 |
(Y1) Disintegration time (Y2) |
62.983 |
1.289 |
20.284 |
10.359 |
2.415 |
Table 6: Observed and predicted values of the responses for the optimized metoclopramide Fast dissolving orodispersible Film (F9)
Response |
Observed value |
Predicted value |
Residual |
In vitro drug release (Y1) |
100 |
98.82 |
-1.18 |
Disintegration time (Y2) |
151.2 |
163.96 |
12.76 |
Stability study
After subjecting all formulations to stability studies at 40 °C/75 % relative humidity (RH) for a period of 3 mo, samples were withdrawn at time intervals of 15 d and evaluated for physical parameters, pH, drug content, and drug release. The stability studies revealed no significant differences before and after storage for the all formulations.
CONCLUSION
The main aims and objective of the present study was to formulate, design and optimize fast dissolving oro-dispersible films of metoclopramide HCL at various concentration of film forming polymer (HPMC E5) and superdisintegrant (sodium starch glycolate) by using 32 multi factorial design and to evaluate their influence on the percent of in vitro drug release and the disintegration time. The films were prepared using solvent casting method using HPMC as polymer and SSG as a super disintegrant. HPMC was selected as the polymer used for their matrix forming properties while sodium starch glycolate (SSG) is used for its super disintegrant effect. The study shows that the use of 32factorial designs are valid in predicting the optimized formulation which was found in formulation F9 as the observed values were very close to the predicted ones, and in which hydroxypropyl methyl cellulose (E5) was used as a film forming polymer in its high level (3.5%) in addition to sodium starch glycolate in its high level (2%). The stability studies revealed no significant differences before and after storage for the selected formula.
CONFLICTS OF INTERESTS
All authors have none to declare.
REFERENCES